Female Agents in ‘Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.’ Are Not Cookie Cutter

By the numbers, it’s clear that “Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” is here to stay. As with any TV show pilot riding on studio-supported hype and fans with high expectations, “Agents” has more than a few critics on entertainment websites – including comic book expert and Marvel alum Jim Steranko, who wrote a negative review of the show on The Hollywood Reporter.

Everyone is entitled to his or her opinion, especially a respected individual who helped shape, define, and illustrate the very origin stories that “Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.” is built upon.

However, Steranko’s comments about the women in the series are particularly irksome:

“Did anyone notice all the women were cookie-cuttered, dressed the same, looked the same, had the same kind of edge (possibly more than their male counterparts)? In the Act 1 apartment fight scene (orchestrated in the Bourne manner), could anyone determine who was doing what to whom (all those black suits)? Anyone wonder how the superpowered Hooded Hero could be so easily tailed (perhaps for days) by hot babe Skye? And why didn’t the S.H.I.E.L.D. interrogators at least get her last name, not to mention her phone number?”

The Cookie Cutter

Perhaps the differences in the females in this ensemble of characters is particularly notable because, you know, half of them are actually women. Or maybe it’s because Skye (Chloe Bennet) works on the fringe of society without conforming to the manic pixie dream girl trope.

Steranko clearly missed the point: the pilot isn’t just Hooded Hero and “hot babe Skye.” Skye is the star of her own story, and the mysterious hero as well as others in the cast are sometimes supporting characters in her story. Skye is the (rarely portrayed) female anti-hero.

Dress Code

Steranko indicated he was dissatisfied with the way the female characters were dressed. It’s worth noting that most of the female characters in the pilot are depicted at work. Skye works and lives in a van and wears civilian clothes – she’s trying to avoid drawing attention to herself. She looks like she picked her clothing out at a retail store, which increases the believability of her character concept.

Skye (Chloe Bennet) works on the fringe of society without conforming to the manic pixie dream girl trope.

Jemma Simmons (Elizabeth Henstridge) dresses professionally. She is, after all, a well-employed biochemist. Perhaps Steranko missed the fact that Jane Foster (Natalie Portman, “Thor”) and Maya Hansen (Rebecca Hall, “Iron Man 3”) also exist in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and dress as real female scientists would – with comfort and practicality in mind.

Agent Melinda May (Ming-Na Wen) and Agent Maria Hill (Cobie Smulders) also appear appropriately dressed in the pilot – they’re S.H.I.E.L.D. agents. They get fitted, utilitarian uniforms conducive to fighting. And all the male characters in black suits may have been visually confusing, but it was realistic. Agents probably don’t dress to stand out in a crowd.

“Hot Babe Skye”

The show left a bit of mystery as to how Skye tailed that particular superhero for days. She’s definitely committed to her independent mission, but she’s also a bit of a fan – a point that allowed me to very much relate to her character. If there really were superheroes in the world, there would probably be people like Skye.

As was made clear in the pilot, Skye has experience with erasing identities; she even assists our mysterious new hero with this task using her technology. This is evidently how S.H.I.E.L.D. is unable to recover more information about her, garnering a professional interest in her particular skill set.

That, and maybe she got tired of giving out her number to creeps who call her “hot babe.” Clearly, she’s attractive – but she’s more than that.

…And About “That Edge”

Every female character in pilot is somewhat assertive in one way or another. Hill continues to command authority and respect; May is traumatized or affected by a previous incident but kicks ass in battle; Simmons has an equal working relationship with her male counterpart; Skye presents uncompromising interests and beliefs.

However, the most important female character presenting “the edge” is Lola, Coulson’s beloved car. The car embodies and echoes an important theme in the Marvel Universe, one that is also represented by Coulson: use and pay homage to classic methods and ideals, but update them for modern times. Lola encapsulates this perfectly, as do the other characters in the show.

I would never begrudge Steranko the credit he deserves for developing Nick Fury and S.H.I.E.L.D. as staples of the Marvel Universe – however, Whedon, Whedon, and Tancharoen clearly intend to honor the organization’s origin and the history of Marvel with this show. It’s unfortunate that this goes unnoticed to some. As long as Marvel stays true to its origins while adapting and accepting new audiences, it will continue to have success – and by including realistic female characters, it does just that.


Liked it? Take a second to support The Geek Initiative on Patreon!
About Tara M. Clapper 290 Articles
Tara is a lifelong geek and the founder and publisher of The Geek Initiative. Her interests were forged in an early appreciation for "Star Trek: The Next Generation," "Jurassic Park," and many historical fiction and fantasy novels. Tara is a game designer, LARPer, and frequent convention attendee. The author of over 1,000 individual blogs, her content has been featured on HelloGiggles, nordiclarp.org, LARPing.org, and The Billfold. She holds a B.A. in English from McDaniel College and has attended many events as press (including New York Comic Con). Tara has a professional background in marketing and publishing. She lives in the Philadelphia area. A Marvel fan, her favorite superhero is undoubtedly Thor. View her portfolio at: tmc.pressfolios.com.


  1. My brother suggested I’d personally probably this way web site. This individual was entirely perfect. This particular blog post absolutely produced my personal time. An individual can not think about just what sort of bunch time period I’d wasted in this information! Thanks a lot!

  2. I’m ipressed from the quality associated with creating on this internet site. A few a great deal of well considered sources here. I just considered that you could be new to green smoke cigarettes critiques, than by every means appear in and appearance our own products. I know Let me pay a visit to this area yet again shortly. Outstanding, it’s really a great post. Good luck.

  3. Gingrich continues to be left for useless politically at the least two times prior to within this major contest. But splitting the so-called conservative vote may just redound to Romney, who would see that wing on the party split involving Gingrich and Santorum, providing the former Massachusetts governor the opportunity to run up the middle. into Tremendous Tuesday, Romney led with 203 delegates.

  4. Acting for Disney must have voice-overs. Opting for casting auditions for Disney channel to act in this kind of roles makes it paramount for one particular to undertaking their voice using the appropriate characteristics. The voices are largely examined for the Disney cartoons and animations.
    [url=http://www.sonz.eu/shop/stores-selling–canada-goose-winter-jackets-in-vancouver-canada.html]stores selling canada goose winter jackets in vancouver canada[/url]

  5. A substantial phase in direction of escalating the tournament s charitable influence was undoubtedly taken in 2007, with the Nicklaus Kid’s Wellness Care Foundation turning out to be the major beneficiary in the Honda Traditional. The Foundation gives you charitable help for activities which will help to enhance the diagnosis, remedy and avoidance of childhood ailments and disorders. It supports not-for-profit applications and tasks directed at pediatric well being care and health-related solutions with the Children s Clinic at St.
    Canada Geese Mate For Life

  6. That leaves just the finale, directed by a quartet of filmmakers going under the combined name Silence. It picks up yet another group of dippy young people, on their way to a Halloween party, who find themselves in a real haunted house by mistake. It suffers from the fact that we don much care about the protagonists, but earns points for good technical prowess and a genuinely spooky atmosphere that doesn let up until the agreeable finale..

  7. Father was nonetheless modest, quite often hungry to sleep, grandma use only a few peanuts for dad to appease starvation. Dig with weeds, and consume bark to create a living, WanXingZhong endure, but within the vast desolate land takes root in, went quickly to get a life span. Memory that include yellow photographs, obscure.
    shoes promo code

  8. Kelly, a former licensed community accountant who rose up around the monetary aspect of Southwest, has worked to also embody the irreverent tradition – dressing up like Edna Turnblad, the bouffant mother from the musical “Hairspray” for last October’s headquarters Halloween celebration. The query is if he can keep Southwest standing out in the competitors by as considerably. – Jeff Bailey, Feb.
    uggs women

  9. Lifestyle coaches teach self empowerment for customers in search of to take their daily life from the reins. Quite a few many people go on believing that existence is one thing that just washes over them because they passively sit by and notice. The point is usually to start off actively executing some beneficial inside your personal existence, at the least in incremental steps.
    ugg mayfaire cement

  10. If you’re hunting for vibrant colour you are going to be capable of Low cost new era hats select Gucci’s Boston Bag in raspberry red. The company create bags which are to classics and easily obtainable in red that cannot be dismissed. Other concerns that add additional glamour to these bags is imprime enterprise emblem which provides an element of surprise.
    uggs youth size 5 converse

  11. Completely offshore with their very own agent workplace (For Advertising, Requirements Engineering, and so forth.) within the consumer countries. , Sort II firms are supplied with the representative workplace within the client nations in order that they can more correctly get consumer leads and industry their services. Corporations operating in this category are medium to huge sized firms, with an employee pool ranging from 50 to later hundreds.
    Ugg Broome Black leather 5511

  12. With out that, I wouldn’t do that. For those of you who know me properly, understand that I am a correct “connector” and will often introduce you to an individual I know might help and vice versa. She is really a common contributor to Franchise Update and has been featured within the Wall Road Journal, Fortune Little Enterprise (FSB), Achievement Journal, The new York Submit, Franchising Journal, amongst several other publications.

  13. What that can do is make the baseball bat less difficult to swing as opposed to the weight and heart of gravitational pressure getting additional in the palms because it is inside a wood bat. Considering the baseball bat is a lot easier to swing, the participant will have a swing that is more quickly which will lead to the ball coming off the bat quicker. This can be a distinct benefit that A bat made of aluminum has over the wood bat…
    ugg roxy tall sand

  14. Three charged as retailing faux handbags along with Bonita flea field southwest florida all the time ideas

    The lee regional Sheriff’s clinic appraised the selling transacting valuation of the items that are $2.7 million. available for one retail store, this can be second time prior to now two years old, is probably the best raided.

    Jong Ho lee, 58, which two discusses: one in barrier arises and an additional from 610 27th e. SW, collier county, has Lee’s timepieces and jewellery, experienced been booked Friday in line with lee city jail but fronts 20 offender matters of promoting or suggesting for sale by owner counterfeit articles. he or printed earnings to do with $72,500 bond university and as a consequence was launched, jail record indicate to.

    a person premiered as the month of january in pretrial diversion concerning an identical charge january 2007, lee local Clerk pointing to court records series. at the beginning which he used to be rotting in jail on eight crime counts of selling or guaranteeing to buy counterfeit merchandise. all of the california’s attorney’s business enterprise office prosecuted your dog one matter.

    an individual’s better half, Jung Hee shelter, 58, who have provides this naples florida as well coral reefs springs address contact info perhaps, had ordered back into jail directly on three misdemeanor counts of selling or offering available for purchase phony foods. this lady premiered when you finish posting $3,000 merge, arrest court records illustrate.

    jesus Enrique Penalver, 46, 618 se 12th patio, absolutely not. 2, cpe barrier, web pages 5th path cologne and not only just affiliated with Lee’s, already been requested 11 crime numbers associated with the sale or delivering available for purchase counterfeit pieces. the individual offers reserved directly prison weekend quickly shutting himself straight into shelter local deputies. she or he wrote $55,000 attachment coupled with premiered subsequently wednesday.

    to be able to shelter county Sheriff’s business enterprise office stop lists:

    wedding reception 2007 public arrest, products tasked a reputable companies in order to much offers unlawfully by images premiered ceaselessly supervising of the flea specialized niche retailers.

    forward feb.. 14 an undercover private eye accompanying a adventure investigations since computer security got a new Louis Vuitton bank account outside of Jung Hee shelter. researching confirmed previously it was counterfeit.

    A prepare budget purchased such as Jung Hee lee relating to february. 20 became presumably bogus. exactly the same thing day, the most important Sheriff’s firm got a new Burberry billfold that is tested. it became synthetic.

    Deputies went through the flea market so obtained a Chanel carrier Prada in method 5th parfum. those equipment had studied and also viewed as phony. the master, Penalver, is not at the store then.

    An investigator for businesses revealed to deputies the distinction between a knockoff program and that is legal selling in addition to a replica is against the law which.

    with Friday deputies decided significantly more requests on both company. The three experienced been you have to detected.

    Deputies had us dollars and then 36 vast plastic bags most typically associated with counterfeit remedys at two businesses.

    my boy physical lives in about mexico in addition tells you can choose from of these imitations everywhere we look over around. painfully all the underground community. figure they guess when they can depart by using over as well as they should see it over here to check out the quantity suckers they can go to buy. funny enough,plainly, available of suckers!

    the reason why would pay a visit to a flea sell to buy type of equipment unless, that you suppose, BigDogRanch, the actual can’t afford genuine. the nation’s just so imperative to resemble you fit in existance proper. practical ideas on how vain is proper!

    fatally, I acquire several imitations as well as some valid sacks. required to changes of both. I can be assured my best bag based in Hong Kong will be counterfeited, And I be certain that my husband and my container within tuscany is very much real. i must say i uncertainty Gucci the required licenses vendors to be found at hard anodized cookware muskie markets.

    as i’m allowed perceive not actually needing your product or service duplicated, But the luxury market is not actually hurting at the moment. The good affluent continues to spend their cash on newest situation. fashion periodicals will continue to explain to you the Season’s “need to Haves,

    [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=671]Cheap Nike Air Max Kids Shoes White/Gray/Red Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=1227]Cheap Nike Dunk Low SB black Raygun Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=271]Cheap Nike Air Max 87 Shoes Womens White/Blue/Pink/Orange Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=351]Cheap Nike Air Max 90 Shoes Mens Green/Black Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=904]Cheap Air Force One 06 low LE GS White Blue-brght fchs for Women Online Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=1254]Cheap Nike Dunk Low Womens white white lemon light coral Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=483]Cheap Nike Air Max 95 Shoes Mens Black/White Logo Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=464]Cheap Nike Air Max 93 Shoes Mens White/Blue/Light Green Logo Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=90]Cheap Nike Air Max 2009 Shoes Mens White/Black Leather Sale[/url] [url=http://www.asbyatt.com/nike/?id=407]Cheap Nike Air Max 90 Shoes Mens White/Grey Sale[/url]

  15. lots of dark skin and bare stomachs for this faction faction and one of the twins can add something extra
    most of these girls name you will reconized if you have read battle vixens or seen ikkitousen

  16. Great work! This is the type of information that are supposed to be shared around the internet. Shame on Google for now not positioning this publish higher! Come on over and seek advice from my website . Thank you =)

  17. You need too taske part in a contest for oone of the most uswful blogs online.
    I most certainly will highly recommend this web site!

    Visit my site: tax accountant coral springs – Vanita

  18. Ηello there! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know hοw to make your
    site mobile friendly? My web sіte looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone.
    I’m trying too find a theme or plugin that might be able to rеsolve this problem.

    If you have any recommendations, ρlease share. Thank you!

    Here is my homepage; bodycon dresses

  19. While we all love to spoil our pets, there are times that our fur-kids do not
    seem to get the same enjoyment out of a mass manufactured
    product as those that come from an individual crafter.

    Your pet can use it to sharpen her claws without destroying your
    furniture. This means that everyone needs to know what rooms the
    cat is allowed in.

    Also visit my webpage michigan bankruptcy laws

  20. Heyy just wanted to give you a quick heads up.

    Thhe text in your article seem to be running off the screen in Chrome.
    Im not sure iif this is a format issue or something
    to do with web browser compatibility but I figured Id post to let you know.
    The layout look great though! Hope you get the problem resolved soon. Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.